Editor’s Letter
SUCH WAS THE TENOR OF DEBATE inside the New York Yacht Club over a new member, as described by former Commodore Charles A. Dana. It was 1894, and the candidate was no typical tycoon. In fact, she was a woman, widowed at age 40 by steel magnate Thomas Carnegie (Andrew’s brother). Considering her immense wealth—and her equally immense responsibility as mother of nine children—Lucy Carnegie would have been forgiven for retreating to a quiet life of comfort following her husband’s death. Instead she forged on, full steam ahead, pioneering a new path for her family on Georgia’s Cumberland Island. After completing the renovation of Dungeness, her 59-room mansion on the wild barrier island, she cultivated as self-sustaining an existence as possible by developing expansive orchards, raising livestock and crops, and…