Pipe dreams
The country’s public water services are not a “patchwork shambles”, as Listener writer Jane Clifton asserts. This is the same type of exaggerated claim the government has used to push through its politically motivated reforms. There are several reasons for the nationwide angst over Three Waters. First, underlying distrust. The government has arguably brought much of its misery upon itself by not being upfront in its election manifesto about the type of radical reforms being proposed. It therefore had no mandate to pursue them without extensive community consultation, which has not occurred. Second, constitutional change. It is widely acknowledged that Three Waters has major implications for both our constitution and the future role of local government. That being the case, any reform proposals should at least have awaited the current “Future for…